Frederic henry and catherine barkleys relationship problems

Frederick & Catherine: Star Crossed Lovers

Romance on the Italian Front: An Examination of Catherine Barkley as view the quirky relationship between Frederic Henry and Catherine Barkley in Unfortunately, this presents a problem for feminine Eros that culminates with her death. Thus this lack of knowledge and development leads to problems. Even after meeting Catherine Barkley the relationship they have is merely a game to him. Frederick and Catherine's relationship, though seemingly perfect, could never By telling her that he loves her, though he "did not love Catherine Barkley nor had Frederick is too late to stop the cascade of problems they are faced with later.

She know understands the symbolic nature of sex and sexuality, and she realizes that she has discovered something far deeper than any vacuous fling — Catherine, feminine Eros, has found authentic love. The same is true for Frederic. But how can this be the case if the love has developed is awkward, unnatural, and seemingly contrived? Because of the unique situation in which the two are placed: As a result of the stress and pain with which Frederic and Catherine have dealt, the two need love and passion more than ever.

Most importantly, both Frederic and Catherine are young.

Hemingway Suite Part 10 - A Farewell to Arms

This coming of age narrative serves as the cornerstone of the contemporary analysis of feminine Eros. She does not know the extent of her body, her desires, or her emotions. This presents a significant problem. And while Catherine deeply probes her sexuality as her relationship with Frederic continues to develop, her failure to check her libido ultimately leads to her destruction.

That is, Catherine, feminine Eros, in her haste fails to keep her loving styles in equilibrium. She allows her relationship to become lopsided with Eros and deprives the relationship of the necessary balance between passion and pragmatism.

This proclamation begins the downfall, the self-destruction, of feminine Eros, for while Catherine and Frederic both love each Blair 8 other, a baby royally inserts a monkey wrench into their relationship.

Even though Frederic voices his approval, it is already too late. In the beginning, life could not have been better — Frederic and Catherine were madly in love, sexually insatiable, and full of youthful vitality. As the relationship developed, though, obstacles repeatedly appeared in front of their path, causing them to undergo significant hardship. While these obstacles no doubt strengthened their relationship, they heavily contribute to the downfall of Catherine, feminine Eros.

What is more, Hemingway attempts to quantify for the reader the extent of the pain which Catherine, feminine Eros, must endure prior to giving birth.

The pain is just as much metaphoric, if not more, than physical. The pain represents the self-inflicted, self-destructive nature of feminine Eros.

In pursuing authentic love, Catherine has exited her realm of pleasure-seeking. She has entered a world, a relationship, in which a harmonic rapport between passion and pragmatism must exist.

But feminine Eros is a jealous mistress, and this cannot happen. Blair 9 Thus, feminine Eros feels cornered and helpless. She now rests on shaky territory — the territory of complete, fulfilling love, love that uses passion and Eros not as an explanation for existence but as an exploration of deeper consciousness. Rather, Catherine concerns herself more with the happiness that she provides to Frederic, and the happiness that he provides to her.

In fact, Hemingway makes this clear when Frederic and Catherine arrive at the hospital in Lausanne. Even during her excruciating labor pains, Catherine focuses on the happiness that Frederic and the child will provide her in the future: After birthing a stillborn, Catherine repeatedly hemorrhages before tragically perishing. In her death, Catherine succumbs to the self-destruction mechanism of feminine Eros. She has imploded, stripping her suitor of both his lover and playmate.

Unfortunately for Frederic, he realizes this, musing: Poor, poor dear Cat. And this was the price you paid for sleeping together.

This was the end of the trap. This was what people got for loving each other. So now they got her in the end. You never get away with anything. It would have been the same if we had been married fifty times. While he openly questions the very nature of love as Catherine endures the physical and emotional pain of childbirth and inevitable death, Frederic understands that feminine Eros, an intrinsic part of Catherine, is back to seek vengeance. She was hardly ever sick. Catherine has found strength within herself to help lead her through life.

Frederick sees this in her and wants it also. Through his involvement with Catherine, Frederick slowly begins to find is own inner strength, and as a result his of his affair with Catherine he leaves his previous wild life of prostitutes and drink.

He states in the novel that spending the night with Catherine is better then spending the night in a house of prostitution even though his feelings for her are not deep at that time.

He becomes aware of an element of stability in their affair and realizes that the war that he is involved in is too chaotic, so he deserts the Italian soldiers he has been helping. He and Catherine make a life for themselves totally isolated from everything and everyone else.

Frederick elieves that his life is now completely in order and yet he still seems discontented. He never reaches a place of internal peace until the end of the book when Catherine dies and he realizes that he can not be totally dependent on another for happiness in this life.

A Farewell To Arms was a was a well written novel that gives people a whole different perceptive about the people nd events of World War I in Italy. The book was not the least bit confusing when it came to the text and was really an enjoyable book to read.

This book could be appreciated both by the average high school student or an adult looking for a great book. It had an interesting, moving plot that kept the reader interested in the book, and has been appreciated and read for many years by people of all ages.

From reading this book one learns much about Ernest Hemingway himself plus the times and problems of World War I. This book was a classic in and is still seems contemporary today. If a woman were to do anything possible to please her significant other, that charade could not go on forever.

Eventually, had she not died, Catherine would have grown tired of continually tending to not only Frederick's every wish, but also to her child's, had it survived. Catherine is somewhat deliberate here in her subconscious attempt to deny Frederick the chance to know the real her and also in her sabotage of the relationship.

Catherine Barkley and Frederick Henry each have no idea that while they are sabotaging their relationship on their own, the other is as well.

That, however, is the case, and as it becomes more apparent to the reader that Frederick and Catherine are destroying their chance at a wonderful future, it seems less and less likely to the lovers that anything terrible could happen. Though their relationship is filled with many happy moments, it seems that with every action there is a reaction.

This cliche is very common in A Farewell To Arms. When Frederick is developing actual feelings for Catherine, she, in turn, is using him as an escape from the haunting memories of her fiance.

While Frederick is simply looking for a sexual adventure, he is pushed into a serious relationship. Catherine pretends to be the perfect woman in order to please Frederick, so he does not get to know the real Catherine.

Finally, the end of their relationship brings their single acts of sabotage to a closing. Frederick and Catherine have no way of knowing that their tumultuous relationship is soon going to come to a screeching halt.

A Farewell to Arms: Love Story - words | Study Guides and Book Summaries

Like any other relationship, they have had their share of problems, but also plenty of good times. They are responsible, however, for accidently placing a dark cloud over their "perfect on the surface" romance. From the first time they meet, when Frederick "steals" Catherine from Rinaldi to Catherine's untimely death, it is increasingly apparent that it never will or never could have worked out.

In a review of A Farewell To Arms, William Gross states that "if [he was] a member of a conservative, fundamentalist religion, which [he is] not, [he] might construe [Catherine's] death as proof of the biblical passage, 'the wages of sin are death'" Gross 2. This statement presents the idea that perhaps both Frederick and Catherine sabotaged themselves and their unborn child by continuing to live out of wedlock.

This theory is based upon the fact that their relationship was doomed from the beginning and was guided down several wrong paths by the hands of fate. To an outsider, it would appear that Frederick henry and Catherine Barkley have the perfect relationship.

Frederick is loving and willing to do anything for his beloved Catherine. In return, Catherine loves Frederick with all of her being and is faithful to him. On the inside, though, it is obvious that no good can come from their relationship. Based on every incident where they think they are being productive towards their relationship, Catherine and Frederick are actually destroying their relationship.

Frederick's initial standpoint on love, which is that he isn't looking for it, leads his meeting with Catherine to a want for a purely physical relationship on his part. Catherine, however, incorrectly interprets his feelings and throws Frederick into a more serious relationship than he is ready for.

Simultaneously, both Frederick and Catherine are using one another to escape from their inner demons. Frederick wants to leave the war behind while Catherine wishes to get over the death of her fiance. In addition to that, Catherine never allows Frederick to really know her because she "merges" with him into one single entity.

Unbeknownst to Catherine and Frederick, these actions are leading up to the ruin of what could have been the perfect romance.